Cork GAA: Four-point goal on cards again but doesn't address issue of boring lateral play
Carrigaline's Thomas Foley tries to block a long-range attempt from Beara's James Spencer during the Cork ETB U21 football championship. Picture: David Creedon
Gaelic football still has room to improve but after a superb season at inter-county level, it’s surprising the four-point goal is on the cards for 2027.
Mayo’s thrilling All-Ireland triumph capped off a sizzling summer where Westmeath dethroned Dublin to land only their second Leinster title, Louth reached the All-Ireland semi-final and Roscommon upset the odds in Connacht. The two-pointer along with longer kick-outs saw the scoring rates explode.
Raising orange flags was a cornerstone of Mayo’s approach, even if they only nailed four of their 14 in beating Kerry, but goals increased as well at elite level this year.
So why tinker with the rules again? It’s important to remember that a four-point goal was originally proposed when the Football Review Committee started the revamp two years ago.
In recent weeks, during the third-level leagues, they’ve revisited the increased reward for goals, as well trialling a restriction on handpasses, banning fisted points, shorter kick-outs and a backcourt violation rule ala basketball.
None of those are on the agenda for the 2027 league, just a four-point goal and a few technical adjustments.
According to Kevin McStay, the chairman of the Football Expert Advisory Group, "The four-point goal retained significant popularity right throughout the process.
“It’s very important to have great data and the data has been positive on this but if the public don’t like it, it’s going to be a very hard sell. The four-point goal has been popular."
Read More
The upsides of a four-point goal are obvious and appealing. It encourages players to drive towards the small square, eschewing the handy point, and it rewards a towering number 14 inside, as a target man and to pounce on any two-pointers that drop short.
The influence of basketball in modern Gaelic football was highlighted recently by Eamonn Fitzmaurice recruiting double-winning Ballincollig player-coach Ciarán O'Sullivan as part of his Galway management set-up.
Basketball has always embraced change and in the NBA, the rules are regularly tweaked to improve and adapt the sport. The modern era has been dictated by an obsession with three-point shooting as every team followed the lead of Steph Curry’s Golden State Warriors.
Prioritising shots outside the arc left more space inside. Firing up three-point attempts along with increasing high-percentage opportunities at the rim sent the two-point jump shot out of fashion. The mid-range jumper, the staple of legendary scorers like Kobe Bryant and Dwayne Wade, dropped from 31% of all attempts in 2000 to 13% in 2024.

McStay and EAG are clearly wary of goals losing their lustre as counties tweak their tactics to hunt two-pointers. If the four-point goal trial goes ahead, a special congress next autumn would likely be required and you'd need a proper sample size to make a decision. The upcoming league is the obvious arena for that.
However, a four-point goal doesn't address the common complaints GAA supporters have about football, namely, the volume of hand passes and the length of time teams can hold possession in tandem with slow build-up play.
The high press was a feature of the 2026 championship, after removing backpasses to goalkeepers, but if goals are worth four points does minding the ball not become even more important?
The limit on handpasses, where teams had to kick after three handpasses, didn't reduce 'lateral play' according to McStay, while there was huge pressure on referees to keep track of them.
"Referees and players are struggling to keep count... which is very human and to be expected.
"But then you also have these reset, clunky five-metre footpasses and they’re not pretty at all. So it hasn’t really reduced the lateral play that we’d hoped for.
"And we said at the outset that the threshold was going to be savagely high for proposals to make it through. The only one that we could stand over in terms of proposing was the four-point goal."

App?






