Rugby Talking Points: Daunting task for Munster in Bath

Former Munster coach van Graan led the famous club to their first league title in 29 years and they're keen to make their presence felt in Europe
Rugby Talking Points: Daunting task for Munster in Bath

Munster's John Hodnett dejected after the Stormers' loss. Picture: INPHO/Dan Sheridan

At this moment in time, there cannot be too many more daunting tasks in European rugby than having to open your Champions Cup account against Johann van Graan’s high-flying Bath, but that is the task awaiting Clayton McMillan’s Munster this weekend at the Recreation Ground.

Brilliant Bath:

Bath are the reigning English champions and current table toppers in the Guinness Premiership, with them having only lost once in the league this season, a 22-20 loss to Leicester in October, and they are bang on form if last weekend’s impressive 29-36 victory away to Saracens is anything to go by.

Former Munster head coach van Graan led the famous club to their first league title in 29 years last term, and they are now eager to kick on and make their presence felt in Europe.

They have not lost a league or European tie at the Rec in over a year and it is a record they will not be in any rush to relinquish.

Munster captain Tadhg Beirne. Picture: INPHO/Dan Sheridan
Munster captain Tadhg Beirne. Picture: INPHO/Dan Sheridan

Munster’s European record is littered with fabulously unlikely victories on the road, with April’s knockout win over La Rochelle being the most recent. They will require a new addition this Saturday to get the latest European adventure off to a winning start.

Scrum issues:

While nobody was under any illusions around the strength, or lack of, of Munster’s scrum, the theory going into last weekend’s home fixture against the Stormers was that the home front row should be OK given that the Stormers Springboks were all occupied over in Cardiff for the slaughter of Wales.

As notions go, it was a flawed one, as the Munster scrum completely crumbled in the second half, conceding penalty after penalty, and proved the platform for the Stormers to come from 15 points down at half time to win 21-27.

As confidence builders go, it was not great. 

There will be serious concerns over how the set piece will go this weekend against a Bath side who have some substantial heft to call upon for the upcoming front row battle that could well decide the game.

Last weekend Munster started the experienced prop pairing of Jeremy Loughman and John Ryan and while there certainly were no panic stations early on, that all changed when the Stormers unleashed their bomb squad in the 44th minute, when they effectively brought in an entirely new front five. 

Michael Milne, Niall Scannell and Ronan Foxe were all brought on to counter this move, but there was to be holding back the tide. There were a few individual errors that stood out as costing Munster late on, but it was the scrum dominance that really turned the game.

While Munster are scrambling for available tight-heads, Bath can call upon Thomas du Toit and Will Stuart. The Springbok and English internationals both tip the scales at around the 21 and a half stone mark and they are likely to be a tag team pairing that could well turn the tie in Bath’s favour if Munster are unable to counter their scrummaging power. 

Du Toit was briefly a member of the Munster parish when he played half a dozen times in red on a brief loan deal nine years ago. He is a very different animal now to what he was back then.

With the knowledge of what is coming down the tracks, the arrival at Thomond Park of Michael Ala’alatoa could not be better timed. With uncertainty surrounding the short to medium term availabilities of both Oli Jager and Roman Salanoa, Munster find themselves extremely light in the ballast department, so the Samoan’s near 21 stone frame should certainly come in handy over the next few weeks and months.

10 head-to-head:

With Finn Russell pulling the strings behind the formidable Bath pack, if Munster are to have serious aspirations of victory they will require Jack Crowley to be in the other no. 10 shirt on Saturday, with the potential match-up between the pair being worth the entry fee on its own.

If Russell can get the time to unleash his pacy backline of Harry Arundell, Joe Cokanasiga and Max Ojomoh then Munster could be in real trouble.

Reports early in the week suggested that Crowley was “being assessed” following a leg injury sustained in the bruising battle with the Stormers last Saturday, but the club were hopeful regarding his availability. It is difficult to argue a case for a Munster win if they end up being shorn their talisman at 10.

more Cork Rugby articles

Ireland v South Africa - Quilter Nations Series 2025 2027 Rugby World Cup draw: Ireland face Scotland, Uruguay, and Portugal
Jack Crowley scores a try 29/11/2025 Jack Crowley misses out on Bath trip but Munster hope he'll be available for Páirc Uí Chaoimh clash
Edwin Edogbo with Ronan Foxe as he is lifted in the scrum 29/11/2025 David Corkery on Munster rugby: Bath test a true indication of progress

More in this section

Niall O'Halloran departs as Cork senior hurling coach Niall O'Halloran departs as Cork senior hurling coach
Aidan O'Mahony steps down as Macroom football manager  Aidan O'Mahony steps down as Macroom football manager 
Cork v Waterford  - Munster GAA Hurling Senior Championship Round 5 Cork open Allianz HL title defence with Páirc clash against Waterford

Sponsored Content

Skechers launch basketball footwear range ahead of partnership with UCC Demons Skechers launch basketball footwear range ahead of partnership with UCC Demons
The season’s showstopper The season’s showstopper
Businesses in Co Cork towns and villages open for Christmas season Businesses in Co Cork towns and villages open for Christmas season
Contact Us Cookie Policy Privacy Policy Terms and Conditions

© Examiner Echo Group Limited

Add Echolive.ie to your home screen - easy access to Cork news, views, sport and more