HSE chief executive criticised over lack of recent meeting with Cork University Hospital head

The health committee heard concerns about recruitment delays, staffing levels and overcrowding during a tense session focused on the Cork hospital
HSE chief executive criticised over lack of recent meeting with Cork University Hospital head

CUH clinical directors had previously raised concerns about pressures, including limited access to rehabilitation services outside the hospital. Picture: Noel Sweeney

HSE chief executive Anne O’Connor has not met with the head of Cork University Hospital (CUH) “recently”, despite ongoing concerns about patient safety raised by Jennifer Kearney.

She also said she has confidence in Dr Andy Philips, regional executive officer, but declined to say she has “full confidence” in him.

This emerged during a heated session of the Oireachtas health committee, which covered national budgets but focused mainly on CUH.

Ms O’Connor told Sinn Féin health spokesman David Cullinane that she had met officials from the HSE South West region.

However, when asked if she had spoken to the CUH chief executive, she said: “No, not recently”.

Mr Cullinane described this as “extraordinary”, a reaction echoed by other committee members.

Ms O’Connor said: “As a hospital, CUH is not unique in facing huge service pressures. But it is unique in that it appears to be conducting its management business via the media with extraordinary regularity.” 

Responding to Labour senator Laura Harmon’s questions about the minutes of a meeting involving Mr Philips and Ms Kearney, she said: “I was concerned about the minutes.”

Mr Philips had claimed he was told by the Taoiseach’s office and the health minister’s office to have “some very specific conversations” with Ms Kearney. He later apologised for falsely suggesting this.

Ms O’Connor declined to comment further when Labour TD Eoghan Kenny asked whether Mr Philips’ position was now tenable.

Fine Gael TD Colm Burke asked about recruitment delays, saying he knew someone who had left a job in America after being hired by CUH but could not get a start date on arriving in Ireland.

Ms O’Connor told him: “I am absolutely going to go to Cork” and said information was shared with her through the regional structures.

She said of CUH: “their increase in staffing this year is bigger than the combined increase in Beaumont, the Mater, St James and Tallaght University hospitals.”

Committee members disputed the comparison, saying patient volumes, the types of services offered and catchment areas were not directly comparable.

Ms O’Connor acknowledged, in response to Labour health spokeswoman Marie Sherlock, that HSE South West had expressed concerns this week that its applications for recruitment approvals were not being processed quickly enough.

The region is one of four required to submit requests to the HSE and Department of Health on various financial matters.

Committee chair Padraig Rice raised a request from the CUH consultants committee for an independent assessment of staffing numbers.

However, Ms O’Connor said the HSE payroll system already provided her with this information, including the number of staff being paid in September and those on sick leave or maternity leave.

HSE chief clinical officer Dr Colm Henry described a visit he made to CUH in October in response to a question from Fianna Fáil TD Padraig O’Sullivan.

He said it was an “overcrowded department”. He saw patients being treated in corridors and “significant” difficulties moving admitted patients from the emergency department into the main hospital.

He also saw staff under stress but said methods of tracking patients had improved considerably despite the pressures.

CUH clinical directors had previously raised concerns about pressures, including limited access to rehabilitation services outside the hospital.

Dr Henry said he had met the doctors, who raised clinical risks with him and outlined what they were doing to mitigate them.

He said: “I was more concerned with the overcrowding” when pressed on whether the hospital was understaffed.

He highlighted similar pressures at University Hospital Limerick, where the emergency department saw more than 300 patients every day for three days during July.

more #Health news articles

Friedreich’s ataxia: What is it, and how can Skyclarys help patients? Friedreich’s ataxia: What is it, and how can Skyclarys help patients?
Waiting seats for patients in the hospital Hundreds of Cork patients experienced delayed transfer of care due to insufficient discharge facilities
'They really prioritise work-life balance': Cork doctors share their experience of working in Australia 'They really prioritise work-life balance': Cork doctors share their experience of working in Australia

More in this section

Teenager who died in stabbing outside Cork's Kent Station named locally Teenager who died in stabbing outside Cork's Kent Station named locally
Breaking: Man dies after suspected stabbing outside Cork's Kent Station as two arrested Breaking: Man dies after suspected stabbing outside Cork's Kent Station as two arrested
Over 40,000 removed from Cork hospital waiting lists for not replying to HSE Over 40,000 removed from Cork hospital waiting lists for not replying to HSE

Sponsored Content

Protect your investment: Why a licensed estate agent is non-negotiable Protect your investment: Why a licensed estate agent is non-negotiable
JSA Planning strengthens Cork presence as region prepares for next phase of growth JSA Planning strengthens Cork presence as region prepares for next phase of growth
CanesMeno sponsored Menopause: One in four say the biggest emotional burden is the pressure to appear fine
Contact Us Cookie Policy Privacy Policy Terms and Conditions

© Examiner Echo Group Limited

Add Echolive.ie to your home screen - easy access to Cork news, views, sport and more