Taoiseach does not have 'executive authority' to interfere with Kinsale mussel farm plan

Taoiseach Micheál Martin has said that he does not have “the executive authority” to interfere with the approval of a controversial commercial mussel farm at Kinsale Harbour.

His comments come in response to Independent Ireland Cork South-West TD Michael Collins, who raised the issue in the Dáil on Tuesday.

Mr Collins said that the process in which the aquaculture licence was granted is “flawed”.

“The new licence granted leaves many unanswered questions on the planning process for this specific licence,” said Mr Collins.

He said these surround transparency with the licence award, a lack of public consultation, and lack of monitoring environmental impacts.

“This planning application, which will destroy marine, leisure, and tourism activity in Kinsale, is simply flawed,” he added.

“Will you urgently look into this matter, with the department, to stop this damaging plan from going ahead in Kinsale until proper planning guidelines are adhered to?”

In response, the Taoiseach said that he understands the licence was granted following the “fullest consideration” of both public interest and environmental impacts.

“My understanding is that the minister for agriculture, food and marine has determined to grant an aquaculture licence to Woodstown Bay Shellfish Ltd, and that the licensing process involves consultation with a wide range of scientific and technical advisors, as well as various statutory consultees,” said Mr Martin.

“I am informed that the legislation also provides for a period of public consultation, which, for this application, was held in 2019, and re-run in 2021.

“I am told that the decisions in respect of aquaculture licence applications are only taken following the fullest consideration of all consultations and public interest elements, including environmental considerations.

“An appeal against an aquaculture licence decision may be made in writing within one month,” he added.

“So, there is a process here — I don’t interfere in every single process. I don’t have executive authority to do that.”

Speaking to The Echo, Evelyn O’Riordan, who is a member of the Friends of Kinsale Harbour group, said that she is “disappointed” with the Taoiseach’s comments.

“I think [the Taoiseach] should be calling for more investigation into the matter, and for proper release of the documents,” said Ms O’Riordan.

“It’s very hard to make an appeal when we have incomplete information.

“I was disappointed with his [the Taoiseach’s] comments, but I wasn’t surprised — I didn’t expect him to stand up for it.”

A peaceful protest opposing the development will take place at Kinsale Harbour and the Dock Beach tomorrow from 6.30pm, with Ms O’Riordan calling on everyone “young and old” to show their support.

“I would hope that the protest will bring huge awareness to this issue,” said Ms O’Riordan.

“We need everybody out to fill the beach, young and old, the more force we have [the better].”