Man jailed for knife attack on Cork Garda ends appeal
The judge warned that because of the very serious nature of the assault and death threats against the garda, there was a real possibility that the Court of Criminal Appeal would increase the sentence.
A PRISONER serving a five-year sentence for a serious knife attack on a garda, that changed the course of the officer’s working life, was told that he was very sensible to heed the warning to withdraw his appeal to avoid his term being made longer rather than shorter.
President of the Court of Criminal Appeal Mr Justice George Birmingham said to Anthony O’Donnell, of no fixed address, that “this was a case of quite extraordinary seriousness”.
“The options are to leave the sentence as it is, reduce or to increase it.”
The judge warned that because of the very serious nature of the assault and death threats against the garda, there was a real possibility that the Court of Criminal Appeal would increase the sentence.
“His [the injured party’s] career serving the community is at an end, and he is now confined to desk work,” Mr Justice Birmingham said.
The appellant’s barrister, Paula McCarthy, said O’Donnell had now instructed her to apply to withdraw his appeal.
O’Donnell was originally sentenced by Judge Catherine Staines to five years, with the last year suspended in the case, at Cork Circuit Criminal Court.
Sergeant Gordon Crowley said that the injured officer, Garda Tim McSweeney, bravely intervened to protect the man from his own actions and to safeguard a woman and others who were present in the house.
A woman who was present in the house that night put it simply: “I want to thank Garda Tim McSweeney. I believe he saved my life.”
Unfortunately, it came at a high cost for the member of An Garda Síochána who is very well known throughout Passage West and surrounding areas — where he has been based for many years.
Mr McSweeney said: “When I started my shift that day, little did I know the incident would change my life.
He had hoped to serve out his career in the force in Passage West, but now believes that his future with the gardaí will be more office-based rather than on the beat.
Sgt Gordan Crowley said the incident dated back to the evening of March 24, 2022, when Mr McSweeney responded to a call to a house in the Douglas area of Cork, where he was told that a man was not welcome and would not leave.
Mr McSweeney met O’Donnell at the house and found that he was intoxicated and aggressive.
“Initially, he calmed him and escorted him from the house,” Sgt Crowley said.
“As he did so, Anthony O’Donnell went back into the kitchen to retrieve his jacket. He took a sharp knife from the kitchen. He inflicted minor lacerations on himself.
“Garda McSweeney intervened and received cuts to his own hands.
“Anthony O’Donnell pointed the knife directly at him and said he would kill him and kill her [the woman living in the house].
“He assaulted him in a frenzied manner until the armed support unit arrived.
“Garda McSweeney sustained injuries to his hands and back and to his knee,” Sgt Crowley added.
36-year-old Anthony O’Donnell pleaded guilty to charges including assaulting Mr McSweeney, production of a knife during an incident, threatening to kill the garda and a woman at the house, trespassing in a manner likely to cause fear, and obstructing Garda Marie Courtney.

App?

