'No illegality' in RTÉ pay scandal review finds; Staff protest in Cork and Dublin

THE interim deputy director-general of RTÉ, has said former director-general Dee Forbes was “directly involved” in aspects of negotiating Ryan Tubridy’s 2020-2025 contract, including the underwriting of an agreement with a commercial partner.

He said no member of the RTÉ executive board, other than Ms Forbes, had all the necessary information in order to understand that the publicly-declared figures for Mr Tubridy could have been wrong.

Adrian Lynch said the national broadcaster has received external legal advice that there was no illegality in previously undisclosed payments to Mr Tubridy.

“On the basis of the Grant Thornton findings, there was no illegality and payments were made pursuant to an agreed contract.” 

He said the Grant Thornton review makes no finding of wrongdoing on the part of Mr Tubridy in relation to any payments made by RTÉ.

“Ryan Tubridy was not aware of the credit note provided by RTÉ to the commercial partner.” 

He said the review also found no findings of wrongdoing on the part of the commercial partner.

More than one hundred members of staff at Irish national broadcaster RTÉ have staged a protest at its Dublin headquarters, following the scandal involving undisclosed payments to its highest-paid star.

Staff represented by the National Union of Journalists and the Services Industrial Professional and Technical Union gathered on a plaza in the Donnybrook campus of RTÉ to voice their concern over pay, conditions and governance in the wake of the revelations.

Chair of the RTÉ Trade Union Group, Stuart Masterson, said anyone who had involvement in the undisclosed payments had to appear before the Oireachtas committees.

“A company’s culture is led from the top,” he said.

Emma O Kelly, chair of NUJ Dublin Broadcasting Emma O Kelly, chair of NUJ Dublin Broadcasting Branch (Niall Carson/PA) NUJ Dublin Broadcasting chair and RTÉ News education correspondent Emma O Kelly said she hoped the protest would be the start of “serious root and branch reform” in the organisation.

She said: “The public deserves a public service broadcaster they really can trust and be proud of.” 

She added: “We’ve seen talented young journalists walking out the door because this is no longer a place that people feel they have a future in.

“That really makes the rest of us feel really upset, sorry and sad.” 

STAFF ANGER

Caoimhe Ni Laighin, a journalist with the organisation’s Irish-language services, said her co-workers were “performing the miracle of the loaves and the fishes every single day”.

“Our equipment is all falling apart and we have been begging the management for a long time to deal with this,” she said.

RTÉ News crime correspondent Paul Reynolds said he was concerned about the “breach of trust” between management and staff.

“There’s a phrase bandied around in here: ‘We are one RTÉ’,” he said.

“And we can see now we haven’t been one RTÉ because everyone hasn’t been working together, different people have different agendas.

“That has disappointed people here. The trust that people had in here for senior people has been lost.” 

RTÉ News political correspondent Paul Cunningham said there was “a cloud hanging over the organisation”.

He said the scandal had caused incredible reputation damage.

Mr Cunningham warned that the Government and other politicians would be reluctant to engage in reform of the organisation’s funding and the television licence fee.

“This is something that has happened as a direct result of senior management’s failures at this organisation and it is absolutely disgraceful,” he said.

Mr Cunningham also raised the issue of freelancers who he said were “paid a pittance”.

“And now we found out there is a special arrangement for special people,” he said.

“There shouldn’t be any special people in this organisation. It’s one organisation, all of us are involved and the same rules should apply.

RTÉ News Midlands correspondent Sinead Hussey said the day she got her job at the broadcaster was “one of the happiest days” of her life.

“I’m still proud to work for RTÉ and I think with the staff we have here we can bring the name of this company back to where it should be and restore trust in the Irish people,” she said.

“And I hope people will support us through this really difficult patch.” 

The broadcaster’s legal affairs correspondent said staff cannot believe what happened.

Orla O’Donnell said: “We want accountability and responsibility from the people who are in charge.

“We want them to tell the whole truth on the questions that still remain from this whole affair.” 

RTÉ News’s Northern editor and correspondent Vincent Kearney and Conor Macauley protested at a separate demonstration at the organisation’s Belfast office.

Mr Kearney tweeted: “Joining @rtenews colleagues across the island demanding transparency from management on the Ryan Tubridy payments crisis and a pay cap for top earners.”