Dublin dad died from stab wound that severed artery and vein, court hears
Eoin Reynolds
A Dublin father died from a single stab wound to the neck that severed a branch of the carotid artery and his jugular vein, the Central Criminal Court has heard.
Joseph Lawlor (39), of Hampton Wood Road in Finglas, Dublin 11, has pleaded not guilty to the murder of Michael Ryan (51) in a car park to the back of the accused man's home on June 20th, 2024.
The jury has previously heard that Mr Lawlor and Mr Ryan were drinking together in the accused man's home throughout the day and had their first physical altercation at 8:30pm.
Following a second altercation just after 9:30pm, Mr Ryan left in his car but was arrested almost immediately for drink driving. Having been processed and released from custody, Mr Ryan returned to Mr Lawlor's home where the fatal encounter happened.
The trial has heard evidence that an audio recording captured Mr Ryan moments after being stabbed saying: "You fucking c**t you, you dirtbird, Joey. You stabbed me in the artery, you f**king eejit."
State pathologist Dr Yvonne McCartney on Thursday detailed 57 scratches and bruises on Mr Ryan's head, arms, legs and torso. She also noted a stab wound 9.1cm below Mr Ryan's right earlobe in the area above the collarbone.
She told prosecution counsel Kevin White SC that one end of the wound was pointed and the other notched and irregular. Dr McCartney said gardaí showed her a carving knife and bread knife that were found at the scene, either of which could have caused the pattern of the wound.
At least moderate force would have been required to penetrate the skin, she said, and after that the knife would have easily gone through the soft tissue underneath.
The wound was 2.9cm in length and 5.8cm deep. It entered at the base of the neck and severed the subclavian branch of the right carotid artery and the right jugular vein, causing bleeding into and partial collapse of the right lung.
Death would not have been instant, she said, as it would take time for blood loss and the collapse of the lung to cause cardiac arrest.
A toxicology report showed that Mr Ryan had taken cocaine in the hours before his death and he also had benzodiazepines below therapeutic levels. His blood alcohol level was at 1.5 times the legal limit for driving.
Dr McCartney concluded that Mr Ryan died due to the stab wound to his neck.
Under cross-examination, Dr McCartney agreed with defence counsel Seamus Clarke SC that injuries to the back of Mr Ryan's scalp could have been caused when he fell backwards after being stabbed.
Other abrasions and bruises to the face, chest and back could have been caused when Mr Ryan and the accused were fighting and scuffling earlier that night.
Blunt force injuries to the hands could have been defensive injuries or could have resulted from Mr Ryan throwing punches, she said. Injuries to his shins and feet were consistent with kicking, being kicked, or a fall to the ground, she said.
The trial continues before Mr Justice Patrick McGrath and a jury.
