Concerns raised over Cork disability centres

Some 51 complaints were made to HIQA about Cork designated centres for people with disabilities from January 2023 to the end of April 2024. Amy Campbell reports
Concerns raised over Cork disability centres

All complaints are “reviewed by an inspector to establish if the information received indicates a risk to the safety, effectiveness, and management of the service, and the day-to-day care the resident receives.”

Concerns raised at Cork designated centres for people with disabilities (DCDs) over a 16-month period included residents’ rights, safeguarding and the overall running of the centres.

HIQA advised that nationally, they received 12.4% more complaints about DCDs in 2023 than in 2022.

Logs of 51 Cork complaints were seen by The Echo under the Freedom of Information Act, with HIQA advising that a concern can be submitted by a resident themselves, a family member or someone acting on behalf of a resident, members of the public, advocates, health and social care professionals or legal representatives.

In all but two of the months in the 16 month period, there were between none and three complaints, with the exception being six complaints in August 2023 and 26 in November 2023.

November complaints represented more than half of the total number of complaints made to HIQA in the time covered under the FOI request.

All but two of the complaints for November were identical, with someone reporting that they were “concerned about the safeguarding and rights of residents, premises, risk management, and governance and management” of a designated centre for people with disabilities.

The logs did not clarify which centre complaints were made at and if these were all about the same centre, with a spokesperson for the organisation saying: “The same concern was sent to HIQA multiple times during this period. We cannot give any further details.”

In the complaints, residents’ rights, safeguarding and governance and management were the most common concerns – each being mentioned 38 times, with all complaints addressing multiple concerns in a centre and some being concerned about as many as nine areas.

Residents’ rights can cover a range of areas in DCD’s largely to do with their right to be understood and staff knowing how to communicate with residents who have complex needs.

Residents’ ability to communicate or their access to technology and aids to assist them in communicating, whether or not their views are then listened to and taken into account as well as their right to access the internet and news media of their choice are all covered under Regulation 9: Residents’ Rights.

Similarly, safeguarding covers a broad scope of areas, with the majority around protecting residents from all forms of abuse while living in the centre amongst multiple residents who may present with behaviour that is challenging.

Residents being able to report incidents of abuse to staff, staff then reporting incidents to HIQA or relevant authorities including Gardaí depending on the seriousness of the allegations, and safeguards being put in place as a result of these reports are necessary to be marked compliant in this area, which is assessed under Regulation 8: Protection.

Governance and management, the other most common area of concern for people who made contact with HIQA about Cork centres, refers to the overall running of the centre.

If there are insufficient resources in the centre and the needs of residents are not met, the management structure is uncertain or the person in charge is inaccessible to residents and their families, a centre will be marked not compliant in this area.

Frequently, non-compliance in other issues will lead to the governance and management being marked not compliant also, as it suggests issues with their oversight.

There were a further 24 complaints about the premises themselves – several Cork DCDs failed this area in the 108 inspections carried out by HIQA during this period, with premises being a common repeat finding, eg the same issues with the centre have come up on multiple reports.

HIQA will mark a centre non-compliant in this area if the centre is unclean or not kept in a good state of repair, bedrooms are too small or cramped or residents are restricted from accessing areas.

Health and safety hazards can also come under this bracket – if the environment is not deemed to be clean and safe for residents, or the laundry, cleaning and sluicing facilities are found to be unclean, it can heighten the risk of infection transmission.

There were also 10 complaints made about communication, eight about the quality of care residents were receiving including their individual care plans, and five regarding the general welfare and development of residents.

Other issues mentioned by concerned parties included access to healthcare, nutrition and hydration, visiting, the admissions process, positive behavioural supports and staffing.

Though it was not specified which centres complaints were made about, HIQA’s 2023 annual report, published in June of this year, advised that COPE Foundation, which operates nearly 50 DCDs in Cork, was among three providers that had seen standards deteriorate significantly.

HIQA explained: “During the year, we identified a significant deterioration in compliance levels in centres operated by three large provider organisations, COPE Foundation in Cork, Western Care Association in Mayo and Ability West in Galway, which was impacting on the safety and the quality of life of residents in these centres.

“These providers had inadequate oversight of their centres, had not identified when things were going wrong and did not demonstrate a capacity to address the non-compliances identified by inspectors.”

There was a risk that the registration for a range of their centres would be cancelled, HIQA explains, but rather than progressing with that course of action, they were offered an opportunity to participate in a provider level regulatory escalation programme.

The programme facilitated providers to “improve their governance, address the areas of concern in their centres and prevent the cancellation of their registrations, and the associated distress that cancellation causes for residents and their loved ones.”

HIQA notes, “Inspectors continue to monitor these centres.”

A spokesperson for the Cope Foundation told The Echo that it “acknowledges the findings of the HIQA reports.”

The spokesperson explained: “The organisation is working, within the resources available to it, and in conjunction with HIQA and the HSE to continue its efforts to improve compliance.

“Cope Foundation continues to strive to provide the best possible services to the people it supports in designated centres across Cork city and county.”

All of the 51 complaints seen by The Echo were reviewed by HIQA and one of several actions taken to investigate the claims and ensure the safety and well-being of residents.

All complaints are “reviewed by an inspector to establish if the information received indicates a risk to the safety, effectiveness, and management of the service, and the day-to-day care the resident receives.”

A HIQA spokesperson told The Echo: “If HIQA considers that the service provider may not be compliant with the regulations and or national standards, we can respond by asking the service provider to submit additional information on the issue; requesting a plan from the service provider outlining how the issue will be investigated and addressed, using the information on inspection or carrying out an unannounced inspection to assess the quality and safety of the care being provided in the service.

“In addition, where the information indicates that people may be at immediate risk, HIQA will ensure that relevant authorities such as the Gardaí, the Child and Family Agency (Tusla) or the Health Service Executive (HSE) Adult Safeguarding and Protection Team are informed.”

They added: “Each piece of information helps inspectors to form an overall understanding of how the centre or service is being run.

“We have booklets available on our website that explain how to give feedback to HIQA.”

more Cork health articles

Majority of residents at closing Cork dementia unit still ‘awaiting transfer’ Majority of residents at closing Cork dementia unit still ‘awaiting transfer’
Worst October on record for overcrowding at Irish hospitals Worst October on record for overcrowding at Irish hospitals
Cork University Hospital trolley count highest in the country  Cork University Hospital trolley count highest in the country 

More in this section

Over 40,000 removed from Cork hospital waiting lists for not replying to HSE Over 40,000 removed from Cork hospital waiting lists for not replying to HSE
Public urged to consider options for Midleton to Youghal bypass Public urged to consider options for Midleton to Youghal bypass
Cork Airport to unveil 'friendly' new security area next month Cork Airport to unveil 'friendly' new security area next month

Sponsored Content

Protect your investment: Why a licensed estate agent is non-negotiable Protect your investment: Why a licensed estate agent is non-negotiable
JSA Planning strengthens Cork presence as region prepares for next phase of growth JSA Planning strengthens Cork presence as region prepares for next phase of growth
CanesMeno sponsored Menopause: One in four say the biggest emotional burden is the pressure to appear fine
Contact Us Cookie Policy Privacy Policy Terms and Conditions

© Examiner Echo Group Limited

Add Echolive.ie to your home screen - easy access to Cork news, views, sport and more