David Miliband named on panel probing WHO’s coronavirus pandemic response

An independent panel appointed by the World Health Organisation to review its co-ordination of the response to the Covid-19 pandemic has said it will have full access to any necessary internal UN agency documents, materials and emails.

The panel’s co-chairs, former Liberian president Ellen Johnson Sirleaf and former New Zealand prime minister Helen Clark, announced the 11 other members during a media briefing.

They include Dr Joanne Liu, who was an outspoken WHO critic while leading Medecins Sans Frontieres during the 2014-2016 Ebola outbreak in West Africa.

Also named to the panel are: Dr Zhong Nanshan, a renowned Chinese doctor who was the first to publicly confirm human-to-human transmission of coronavirus; Mark Dybul, who led the Global Fund to Fight Aids, Tuberculosis and Malaria; and David Miliband, a former British foreign secretary who is chief executive of the International Rescue Committee.

Members of #IndependentPanel for #Pandemic Preparedness & Response just announced; looking forward to working w/@MaEllenSirleaf, Mauricio Cárdenas, @aya_chebbi, Mark Dybul, @Kazatchkine @DreJoanneLiu @Dmiliband, Thoraya Obaid, Preeti Sudan, Zhong Nanshan #globalhealth #COVID19 pic.twitter.com/BmpoVo2iIZ

— Helen Clark (@HelenClarkNZ) September 3, 2020

Ms Clark said she and Ms Johnson Sirleaf chose the panel members independently and that the WHO did not attempt to influence their choices.

“We look forward to a period of intense work together at a key moment in history. We must honour the more than 25.6 million people known to have contracted the disease and the 850,000 and counting who have died from Covid-19,” Ms Johnson Sirleaf said.

The panel scheduled its first meeting for September 17 and plans to meet every six weeks between then and April.

It expects to brief the WHO on the group’s initial progress in November before presenting a final report next year.

The WHO bowed to calls from most of its member states in May to launch an independent investigation of how it managed the international response to coronavirus after the United States accused the UN health agency of mismanaging the early phase of the pandemic and colluding with China to hide the extent of the outbreak there.

President Donald Trump pulled the US out of the WHO earlier this year after calling the agency a “puppet” of China.

In June, the Associated Press found that China delayed releasing critical information to the WHO, including the virus’s genetic sequence, for weeks in January.

Pleased to have joined @HelenClarkNZ in announcing the panelists for @WHO's Independent Panel for #Pandemic Preparedness and Response, which we have the great honor to co-chair. I look forward to the contributions they will provide through their considerable expertise.

— Ellen Johnson Sirleaf (@MaEllenSirleaf) September 3, 2020

Internal recordings of WHO meetings revealed officials were frustrated at the lack of data-sharing while director-general Tedros Adhanom Ghebreyesus publicly praised China for its speed and transparency.

To uncover how the global response to Covid-19 was managed, “we may ask decision-makers what kept them up at night”, Ms Clark said.

The panel also plans to examine what the WHO and national governments might have done differently had they known more about coronavirus.

She said the WHO had “made it clear their files are an open book” and that the panel members would have access to any internal documents or materials they wanted, although no such requests have yet been made.

As a UN agency, the WHO is not subject to any freedom of information requests and does not routinely make its internal deliberations public.

The panel is financed by the WHO and has its own staff in Geneva, led by Dr Anders Nordstrom, a former acting director-general at the agency.