Coveney ‘deleted texts before Freedom of Information requests’, committee hears

Simon Coveney told the Foreign Affairs Committee that he clears texts from his phone when ‘conversations conclude’, partly out of security fears.
Coveney ‘deleted texts before Freedom of Information requests’, committee hears

Cate McCurry, PA

Simon Coveney said he had deleted text messages he exchanged with the Tánaiste from his phone before Freedom of Information requests were submitted by journalists.

A series of requests seeking copies of correspondence between the pair were made by reporters and politicians after the appointment of Katherine Zappone to a UN role was agreed by Cabinet in July.

The Minister for Foreign Affairs was quizzed by an Oireachtas committee on Tuesday over the now deleted exchange between himself and Leo Varadkar.

Mr Coveney told the Foreign Affairs Committee that he clears texts from his phone when “conversations conclude”.

“I think it’s prudent to remove information on my phone that is no longer relevant,” he told the committee.

“In other words, if I have had a text conversation with somebody that is done and dusted and we are moving on from it, I would often clear that unless there is a reason to hold on to it.

“Certainly, when I had the text exchange with the Tánaiste, I regarded that matter as closed and I removed it from my phone in the same way as I do with lots of other text exchanges with people.

“I was subsequently very pleased the Tánaiste published those texts because I think they backed up the thrust of what I said to the committee last week when I volunteered the information.”

Last week, Mr Varadkar released a series of text messages between himself and Mr Coveney and Ms Zappone.

Katherine Zappone appointment
Text message exchange between Tánaiste Leo Varadkar and Minister for Foreign Affairs Simon Coveney about Katherine Zappone (Leo Varadkar’s office/PA)

The text messages revealed that, on July 19th, Mr Varadkar asked his Fine Gael colleague about Ms Zappone becoming the UN special envoy on freedom of expression.

The texts were released following a number of unsuccessful Freedom of Information requests, as Mr Coveney told a previous committee that he had deleted the texts.

Journalists were told that the records did not exist.

It is an offence to destroy any record which is subject to Freedom of Information legislation.

Mr Coveney told the committee he had deleted the texts before the Freedom of Information requests were made.

“I do clear texts from my phone when conversations conclude,” he added.

Tánaiste Leo Varadkar released a series of text messages between himself, Minister for Foreign Affairs Simon Coveney and ex-minister Katherine Zappone (Brian Lawless/PA)

Mr Coveney said he does not “hold on to data” on his phone after his device was previously hacked.

“There is a security element to that – I don’t want to overplay the security issue but it is an issue for me,” he added.

“I delete messages when conversations conclude as a matter of course, when I don’t think it is necessary to have text messages; because something is concluded I would often clear the phone of those text conversations.

“I cleared it very shortly after that conversation. I didn’t hang on to it.


“If I was trying to hide the existence of text messages, I wouldn’t have made all of the text messages available to FOI.

“I have not tried to hide anything here.”

Independent senator Gerard Craughwell asked Mr Coveney whether he had requested an encrypted phone from his department.

The Minister replied: “The phone I used has been issued to me by the Department of Foreign Affairs.

“I am conscious about the use of the phone because it has been compromised, it is a matter of public record.

“Officials determined that this incident entered the realm of a cyberattack and made the appropriate notification to An Garda Síochána and the National Cyber Security Centre.”

More in this section

Sponsored Content

Contact Us Cookie Policy Privacy Policy Terms and Conditions

© Evening Echo Ltd, Linn Dubh, Assumption Road, Blackpool, Cork. Registered in Ireland: 523713

Add to your home screen - easy access to Cork news, views, sport and more