Four years in jail for biting off cellmate's ear in Cork Prison
A garda told Cork Circuit Criminal Court that the victim was not convicted on the matter for which he was in prison in the first place. Picture: Dan Linehan.
A 45-year-old man had his ear bitten off by a prisoner with whom he was sharing a cell at Cork Prison in a completely unprovoked attack and today the culprit was sentenced to a four-year jail term.
Judge Helen Boyle noted that Roman Becvár was diagnosed with schizophrenia and that this violent attack was carried out during a psychotic episode.
The 45-year-old victim of this serious assault under the Non-Fatal Offences Against the Person Act had no previous convictions of any kind and was only remanded in custody for a period of days before his ear was bitten off.
Detective Sergeant Kieran O’Sullivan said at Cork Circuit Criminal Court that in fact, he was not convicted on the matter for which he was in prison in the first place.
28-year-old Roman Becvár pleaded guilty to the crime. The victim, who was 45 at the time of the attack in April 2023, “does not understand why the assault happened – he got on well with the defendant,” Det Sgt O’Sullivan said.
“The injured party was sharing a cell with the accused for approximately one week. There were no issues between them. The injured party did not remember the incident happening.
“He was lying on the bunk bed, about to go asleep. He remembered Mr Becvár asking him for tobacco. He did not have any. The next thing he remembers is Mr Becvár banging on the inside door of the cell.
“Roman Becvár was standing against the back wall of the cell with his hands up, blood on his hands and clothing.
“Fortunately, there was a nurse in the area who was on the scene almost immediately.
"He was taken to Cork University Hospital for treatment and he remained there for a number of days.
“Roman Becvár had cuts to his knuckles. CCTV was harvested. No other people entered the cell which was locked at the time. He claimed he was acting in self-defence and that the injured party attacked him. He denied biting off his ear (when first interviewed).
“The injured party had no injuries consistent with carrying out an assault, but Mr Becvár did,” the detective said.
While the severed ear was brought to hospital when the injured party was taken there by ambulance it was not possible to reattach it and he has opted not to have a prosthesis. The defendant was serving a three-year sentence at the time for carrying out an aggravated burglary, with the last year suspended on condition that he would leave the country within seven days of his release from prison. However, he has been remanded in custody for this serious assault on April 9, 2023.
Defence senior counsel Elizabeth O’Connell said the defendant had a “diagnosis of psychosis, possibly up to schizophrenia.”
Judge Boyle imposed a sentence of four years and six months with the last six months suspended. Paula McCarthy prosecution barrister confirmed that the sentence being served by Mr Becvár in April 2023 was completed a year later but he had been remanded in custody afterwards on this assault charge. For that reason the sentence of four years was backdated to April 2024.
Judge Boyle said of the injury: “He suffered an almost total avulsion of his left ear and a cheekbone fracture. He will never have what looks like a normal ear again and the shape of his face is also altered."
The judge said that, consistent with case law, the background mental illness of the defendant had to be taken into consideration as a factor reducing the culpability. She said that the psychotic episode may have been caused by drug use but that there was no evidence of drugs being taken in prison in the days before the assault, according to the toxicology report on the accused.
App?
